The appellate tribunal noted discrepancies between the amounts recorded in the resolution professional’s compliance certificate and the distribution calculations shared by SBI Caps. It also held that dissenting creditors could not be compelled to accept securities in place of the monetary payment required under the Code.
Although the NCLT had directed payment in cash instead of debentures, the NCLAT held that this amounted to modifying the resolution plan. Such changes had to be considered by the CoC.
Significantly, lenders representing 94.98% of the voting share, who had initially supported the plan, subsequently sought its reconsideration, citing concerns over the steep haircut and the treatment of stakeholders.

